Week Woman

A Pox on the Patriarchy

Delhi a month on – a step forward?

Emma Finamore

A month ago today, on the 16th December 2012, five men and one teenage boy were involved in the brutal rape and murder of a female student in delhi gang rape the Indian city of Delhi, as she and a friend returned home from a cinema trip on the bus. The specifics of the case – that the woman was also assaulted with a metal pole, that she and her friend were stripped before being dumped from a moving vehicle, left naked and dying in the street, that she has been publically identified (usually illegal under Indian law) – are gripping the public, almost in chime with the current penchant for violent Scandi-drama. Perhaps even more disturbing though is the wider backdrop to the crime, which many of us have only just become aware of: one of violence, fear, misogyny and lawlessness.

A month on, after unprecedented international media attention and local pressure from on-the-ground protesters and activists, does it look like Delhi – which accounts for 25% of all rapes in a country of 1.2 billion people – can really make the change people are crying out for?

The city authorities have announced a number of new safety proposals, including:

-        The introduction of CCT V on public transport

-        More police patrols at night

-        Checks on drivers and their buses

-        The banning of buses with tinted windows

-        The recruitment of more female police officers

-        A new helpline for women in distress, connected with all police stations in the city

Although useful (if actually put into practice) many of these proposals seem limited to only preventing future crimes very similar to the one that has recently hit the headlines. What of the other crimes, not taking place on public transport but on the streets and in the homes of Delhi?

Four fifths of women report that they fear for their safety on Delhi’s streets at night, unsurprising when much of the city is made up of sprawling slums:  a lack of town planning has resulted in many residential areas which are not lit properly and are not served adequately by the city’s infrastructure. Women’s fears are also understandable when you look at how many of them have already experienced sexual harassment or rape: 80% of women in the city claim that they have suffered this. Would the proposed increase in police patrols at night, and a helpline, genuinely minimise the risk and make women less fearful?

Ironically, if you visit the Delhi Police website (www.delhipolice.nic.in) you can see that one of their top priorities is to “Provide a safe environment to working women who work and return during the night”. What of the women who go out at night to be sociable? Do they not deserve protection?  And where was this “protection” when that 80% of women were being assaulted? The public rhetoric of the police and the reality on the ground seem to be miles apart from one another.

While our attitude to rape in the West is not exactly something to write home about, this lack of action is almost unsurprising when you look at the wider cultural backdrop in which this particular attack took place: one in which women are far too often treated as second class citizens, and that relieves men of responsibility, but paradoxically treats females as incapable of engaging in anything but domestic life and demonises those who adopt more ‘Western’ habits. Let’s take a look at a few examples to put violence against women into context: in 2012 a Unicef report showed that 57% of Indian boys and 53% of Indian girls (aged 15-19) believe that wife-beating is justified; recently a legislator in Rajasthan proposed banning skirts in girls’ schools as a way of preventing rape; and in December at a public rally, while discussing compensation for rape victims, senior CPM MLA and former West Bengal minister Anisur Rahman asked Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee  just how much she would “charge” to get raped. Even a self-styled spiritual leader, Asaram Bapu, accused the woman raped as she travelled on a bus as being “as guilty as her rapists” and defended her attackers:  “The five or six drunken men were not the only ones guilty. The girl was also responsible… she should have called the culprits ‘brothers’ and begged them to stop.”

When and how will responsibility for sexual assault be lifted from the shoulders of the victim? When will domestic violence not be seen as the norm by teenagers? When will women who dare to step forward be viewed with admiration rather than scorn and suspicion? One can understand the frustration and anger of the people taking to the streets, but this is something that legislation and the law can only take so far: more police patrols, helplines and stronger sentencing seem tokenistic if authorities (and citizens) don’t or can’t change their attitudes towards reporting sexual violence and dealing with its victims, and towards women in general.

At least one proposal from officials seems like it could start to bring about change: the recruitment of more female police officers.  In a country where many men chastise and blame victims of sexual assault, it’s hardly surprising that women find it difficult to talk to male officers (indeed this is the case anywhere in the world). In Delhi, only 7% of officers are women, and of this low number barely any are ever out on patrol, so are very unlikely to be approached by women who have been attacked. If a victim of assault made it to one of the 161 district police stations in the city, in only one of these stations would she find a female house officer. So, simply recruiting more women will not have an impact: the deployment of these women also needs to be carefully considered:  if the city can get this right then the plight of the assaulted woman may begin to change.

In terms of this particular case, the knee-jerk reaction from both public and state, vehemently calling for the death penalty is like sticking a small plaster over a massive wound. A holistic approach is needed for a real effect to take hold: in the home, in education, in the media, with leaders of the tribal communities. Delhi needs to reach for long-term change; killing these men will not achieve that.

9 comments on “Delhi a month on – a step forward?

  1. smgcesario
    January 22, 2013

    Reblogged this on smgcesario.

  2. smeebubbles
    January 20, 2013

    An interesting read, thank you. I agree with you that these measures are barely more than tokenistic and it’s frightening to see the statistics of how many young people are ok with domestic violence. Clearly this is a deeply embedded issue of attitude and culture (and we in the West are not immune to it either – my most recent blog post was on the same topic) that will not be resolved in a matter of days and new security measures, but in a long-term educational approach.

    • Thanks very much for your comment – I’ll definitely take a look at your blog, sounds really interesting. I also need as much guidance as possible at this early stage of my “online writing” career and you sound extremely eloquent!

  3. My Heathen Heart
    January 18, 2013

    Gut-wrenching post, Emma.

    Can’t help but wonder why the world in general has felt so threatened by women for thousands of years, that we were (and still largely are) reduced to being ‘worthless’, but for showy and utterly useless political lip service. Religious ignorance hasn’t helped, either.

    I agree, ‘an eye for an eye’ mentality changes nothing; it’s just a shallow display of insincerity.

    • Thanks very much for the positive comments – it was hard to get across everything in a relatively short piece (indeed, I couldn’t get it all across!): hopefully enough people believe in a more sustainable approach to justice that at some point the death penalty will be wiped out.

  4. Rascal
    January 18, 2013

    Hey I like what you’ve written but I’d just like to add a point of contention.

    The problem with India and indeed South Asia as a whole is that their justice systems are systems in name only. The courts and the police are so corrupt that criminals are seldom adequately punished for their crimes – if they are punished at all. Thus when something like this happens, the people who have little to no faith in the system, push for extreme measures like the death penalty; for them it’s perhaps the only justice they can guarantee. It’s hard for us as Westerners to compute this kind logic, but we need to understand that for South Asians it may be the only outcome they can rely on. Hopefully modernisation will allow for a better justice system to imerge in India and thus a more modern, and humane punishment might be meted out.


    • Thanks, that’s a really interesting point that I hadn’t considered. You’re right – we can’t necessarily project our ideas about a judicial system onto another which is so different.

      There are also some really interesting statistics on the number of judges per capita in India (very, very few) which is in part to blame for the low conviction rate. Maybe this could further explain the public’s hunger for quick (and like you said – guaranteed) justice in a crime where the perpetrators have actually made it into a court.

  5. youssra
    January 18, 2013

    (The Benediction of God on her, May God accepts this martyr in paradise)

    Well I agree on some point with you- but I really don’t understand the shortcut most people tend to do when calling women who want respect Western women. I think I deserve Respect but don’t tell me I am a westerner. Women can free themselves without adopting a “western” life style because first we here in Western countries are waaaay far from perfect concerning women rights and secondly because you don t have to deny yourself, your culture and your identity to get respect. Getting tired of the Western suprematie in every field.

    I think all this measures are bullshit we need a mind revolution before material revolution. Children and adults need education on the subject, we surely also need some stronger repressive measures against rapist and pedophiles.
    I will add that if they want to hire more women in police to harass them and make them live a nightmare I don’t think it is a good idea. or better like in France to send them to open the way to the male cops: Recently they send two french lady cop to arrest a bodybuilder beast. He took their weapon and killed them. One was a mother of three…

    • Thanks very much for reading and thanks for your comment. I agree entirely with you on the measures not being enough, and that a “mind revolution” is needed, and (at least to some extent) stronger measures against criminals of this kind.

      I definitely do not believe that the West have got it right (far, far from it), or that only women with “Western” attitudes and behaviours are free, but I do belive that those who want to live that way have a right to do so without fear.

      My main point was that the police measures are not enough – and on this point I think we agree.

Comments are closed.


This entry was posted on January 18, 2013 by in Features and tagged , , , , , , , , , , .

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 30,287 other followers

%d bloggers like this: